Skip to main content

Summer Reading Manifesto

Someone posted on our state library list-serv earlier this week about teens and summer reading:

Do any libraries have a special policy for allowing teens to use graphic novels as part of the summer reading program?  We have a prize for the most pages read & are concerned that the teens reading classic novels are being cheated by the ones reading graphics.  We thought about having a
word count instead of a page count...Any input would be greatly appreciated!

 Here is my (slightly-edited) response to the question's asker: 

Our teens are allowed to read whatever they want. I urge you not to think that graphic novels are "cheating". Some of them are "serious works of art" and some are serious fun. Should summer reading be a competition (what "cheating" implies) or should it be to encourage reading for fun?

When I was in high school, I liked reading all sorts of genres. I would have been mortified and/or very angry if a librarian told me what I was reading was cheating or not a real book. I spent 9 months of the year being told by adults what I had to read for school. I didn't have time to read for fun when I was a teen between school, sports, a job, and other extracurricular activities. Breaks from school were the only time I got to pick whatever I wanted to read.

Some kids like to read classic novels and many don't. Would we place this kind of judgement on adult reading material?

You might also wish to change your program and explore the idea of counting something other than pages read. We switched from pages read to time spent reading and have never looked back. It's less math for us and it levels the playing ground for slower readers. 

One of the things I like most about being a Children's Librarian is that I am not a teacher. I get many (most) of the pros of being a teacher but I don't have to deal with standardized tests and many of the other cons of today's educational system. The kids come here (for the most part) because they want to. No one that works here is going to force a kid to read anything. How wonderful is that!

Kids can (and do!) roam the stacks for hours picking up books left and right. If they don't like it, they can put it back. If they do, they can take it home or read it here.  It is not my job to teach them how to read. It is my joy to show them how much fun they can have reading. I'd like to see Google do that.


  1. I agree. We count books read in our summer reading club. We have a restriction that you can count 1 magazine, cartoon, or comic book for every 5 books read. Read five in a row? Great, one per list. I don't like restricting things read either, but it's seems the most fair.

  2. Hear hear! Thanks for posting this. I have been debating about responding myself, but I haven't found a non-snarky way to do so. What would this non-classics-are-cheating person have to say about our program, in which teens (and everyone else) can actually do other things, too, like come to library programs or check out Museum Adventure Passes? Surely we're encouraging subversive behavior and ruining it for the classics-readers.

  3. Anne--

    My basic goal is to have as few rules as I can get away with. And reading graphic novels can't be cheating if there isn't a rule against it. There is nothing stopping the classics-kids (and I'm sure that so many kids are knee-deep in "the classics" this summer) from reading something "easier".

    I am so jealous of your awesome summer reading program. It sounds so amazing. Let us know how it turns out... I bet there's a lib journal article in it for y'all. Did you see David Lee King's post today about putting SRP stats as the background image on public PCs? I love that idea.

    I tried to stay away from being snarky as much as I can. But I don't know what people are thinking sometimes.

  4. Honestly that's also why I much appreciate counting time read as opposed to pages read. If someone is a slow reader but they sit down and put in the effort of reading 10 pages but it takes them 30 minutes to me that should count the same as the kid who sits down and reads 3 books in that half hour.

  5. Reading is reading. When will we learn this? When will we stop making judgments on what people want to read? Would we tell an adult participating in summer reading who was reading Maus and Blankets that they needed to read some "real" books? No? Then why do we do this to teens?

    Your response was much more polite than I would have managed.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Program Idea: Parachute Playtime

This summer I offered a parachute playtime for kids 2-3 and 4-5. The idea for this program came from the genius that is my close personal friend Miss Lisa, so make sure you stop by her blog to see what activities she includes in her parachute programs. In addition to her program, I also got ideas from Parachute Play by Liz and Dick Wilmes

I like to do a lot of nursery rhymes with the parachute for a few reasons:
Parents/kids are more likely to participate in activities where the content is already familiarI already know them so I don't have to learn a whole bunch of material at once (just being honest here)Easy for the families to replicate this activities at home with whatever props they might have. If they (or you!) don't have a parachute, a bed sheet or blanket can be substituted easily. Even a beach towel would work for one parent and one child to play together.  This is my mean reason and I tried to hammer this in at all three programs I did the past two weeks! Parachute …

"Sleeping Bunnies" on the Parachute!

Here's one of my favorite parachute activities! I actually mentioned it a few months ago when talking about my summer parachute playtime but it's become a storytime staple since. We've been doing this here at my 2 and 3 year old storytimes and it's a great activity that I thought deserved its own post. I learned the song "Sleeping Bunnies" from Mary and I had the idea to adapt it to a parachute activity.

We use the version from Kathy Reid-Naiman's Tickles and Tunes CD.

Here are the words:

Sleeping Bunnies
See the little bunnies sleeping til it's nearly noon. 
Come and let us gently wake them with a merry tune. 
Oh, how are still. 
Are they ill? 
Wake up soon. (Here I yell "WAKE UP BUNNIES!" and the kids shake the parachute.)

Hop, little bunnies, hop, hop hop! 
Hop, little bunnies, hop, hop hop! 
Hop, little bunnies, hop, hop hop! 

Then we say "good night" to the bunnies and repeat a few times.

Today's Flannel Friday is hosted by Cate! 

A Year's Worth of Library Display Ideas (part 1 of series)

One of my favorite things to do in my library is create displays. I thought it might be helpful if I shared the calendar that I drew up to make sure I don't miss any of the "must-do" displays. It is so helpful if you can take people over to a seasonal display versus trying to look up in the catalog or find Easter books or whatever. I hope this helps any new librarians who might be overwhelmed by the process of marketing your collection!

As a general rule, I tend to keep displays up for about 3-4 weeks or if I run out of books all together. One tip I'd recommend if you have the space for multiple displays is to change one display in each space every week and rotate around the youth department like that. For example, one week you put up a new picture books display, then nonfiction, then YA/teen, etc. Don't forget to raid your CD and DVD collections for a multi-category display.

A great resource for making display is Chase's Calendar of Events, which is a prett…