First of all, I learned that I perhaps have NOT picked the wrong career entirely as I had a great time and people seemed to enjoy themselves. The last book that I read, in particular, was a great crowd-pleaser.
Here is the general outline of what went on:
Read Jake Gander: Storyville Detective in the Case of the Greedy Nanny by George McClements
Read Where's the Big Bad Wolf? By Eileen Christelow
Did craft (made detective hats and magnifying glasses)
Read The Search for the Perfect Child by Jan Fearly
Read Mystery Mansion by Michael Garland. This one was a big hit, and by the end of the book, I had what WERE very shy children at the onset of the program half-crawling into my lap to look at the illustrations. This would make a great gift and even teaches counting (as there are more than 400 animals hidden throughout the book)